TGFiction COTTAGEPUNK

TGFiction.Net

Stories that take root by day and glow after dark.

Reviews For To Friends
You must login (register) to review.
Reader note

Annette

Signed · 27 Feb 2009 - 04:13 pm · To Friends [Report This]

Hmmm.  Interesting. A little surprising that "Donna's" little birth defect didn't get found out during the week...  But, people see what they expect.

I think the story could have been more impactful, or immediate with more dialog... but it would have been much longer then.

That Dad comforted mom while child sleeping was interesting.

Thanks,
Annette

Reader note

Annette

Signed · 27 Feb 2009 - 03:55 pm · To Friends [Report This]

Intresting story.  It's really too bad that the two girls were not willing to REALLY remain friends with Dennis once Donna was gone...  Seems they are not as open minded as they might think.  Are Dennis and Donna different people?  Once Dennis learned his lessons, did he remain a prankster as Dennis?  It didn't SOUND like it... So why the reaction - other than cultural brainwashing.

Reader note

Barbara

starstarstarstarstar

Signed · 02 Feb 2009 - 10:16 am · To Friends [Report This]

The ening still has that "be Dennis now and then" ring to it. What I would like to see is Dennis being Donna permanently and Dennis fades into obscurity in Donna's subconscious.

I really liked reading this story, it is well thought out, and the punishment fitting the crime really led to a softe way of life for Donna, and Donna made new friends because of it.

I am waiting patiently for thenext chapter.

Barbara

Signed · 20 Jan 2009 - 11:03 am · To Friends [Report This]

I think it was terribly unfair of Dennis's mother not to give Dennis a real chance as a boy again after the punishment was over.  Nothing was said about him misbehaving in any way during the three days before Mom sprung the new punishment on him; he did not deserve it. 
starstarstar

Signed · 11 Jan 2009 - 12:56 pm · To Friends [Report This]

     Cute story but not much depth.  I wlll take it as is , but would be nice to deal with the real issues that are going to become huge soon.  Showing by telling in terms of many details, strong  emotions, and painfull crisis could be more memorable and allow us to attach to the characters in a greater way.  Am really enjoying this though, don't get me wrong.

     Hugs, Kristi

Reader note

Linda Jeffries

starstarstarstar

Anonymous · 03 Jan 2009 - 05:47 pm · To Friends [Report This]

OK, so the mom was a bit unilateral in her decision.  in the end, it all worked out for Donna, her family, and, her best friends.  An excellent read that got the waterworks fowing.  Thanks for the pleasure of reading it.
Reader note

Jezzi Stewart

Anonymous · 22 Mar 2008 - 04:01 pm · To Friends [Report This]

I was enjoying this story, till it got to mom unilaterally deciding that he had to remain a girl after his punishment was completed.

 

<< His mum turned to him and smiled, "Yes I'm so proud of the way you've behaved, your school report was your best ever. So if you think I'm going to let mischievous Dennis start next term in place of my diligent daughter Donna think again. I was putting your education first when I agreed to the headmaster's condition and I'm going to do it again now. Besides you would lose Becky & Jo as best friends." >>

 

This was totally unfair, even though it worked out well.  Dennis had completed his punishment and mom admitted she was proud of him, yet he was given no chance to prove he had learned his lesson.  What was mom's plan if he had truly hated it and felt completely betrayed, as he had every right to feel.  Sorry, but I lost all respect for mom at this point.  Mom should have given him a chance; my guess is he would have come around to what mom wanted on his own. 

Reader note

whildchild

Anonymous · 19 Feb 2008 - 06:31 am · To Friends [Report This]

verry good ilike it something new and it was verry good and i wood love to see more storys like this it is deft than a lot of the others we need more frash storys more like this

 have a good one love n hugs awalys  

                      [email protected]       
 

Reader note

Renee M

starstarstarstar

Signed · 30 Jan 2008 - 10:32 pm · To Friends [Report This]

That was so sweet, I almost started to cry.  I bet most TGs feel the same way.  "Why couldn't I have such a loving and understanding family?"

Hugs'

Renee 

Reader note

harry reimers

starstarstar

Anonymous · 01 Nov 2007 - 01:07 am · To Friends [Report This]

i just loved this story is any more to it i hop so do not leave us hanging here wot happins next do thay all go of together or do thay split up
Reader note

Karen J.

starstarstarstar

Anonymous · 02 Oct 2007 - 12:41 am · To Friends [Report This]

A sweet story, Cat.  Sure would be nice to see some more about Donna when you have the time.

KJT

You must login (register) to review.